黄雅博
回复 吴婉瑜 :突击魔鬼岭一部典型的阳刚派战争片。内容讲述五名各有所长的美国大兵组成突击队，突破了德军在欧洲战场构筑的齐格飞防线，占据碉堡之后予以死守。影片在内容上虽无新颖之处，然而史蒂夫．麦奎因、詹姆斯．科伯恩等要角搭配整齐，导演唐．西格尔的手法硬朗有力，拍出了强烈而刺激的战争气氛。
张雅正
回复 刘佳玉 :校园突击MaskedfigureswithmachinegunsmarchintothesecondaryschoolinKaratas,takethepupilshostage,andexecuteoneofthem.Theymakenodemands.Silentterroristheirmodusoperandi.Seeingasthearmywilltaketwodaystoarriveduetoasnowstorm,mathsteacherTazshidecidestoassemblehisownassaultteam:hisex-wife,thegymteacher,thecowardlyschoolprincipal,analcoholicnightwatchman,thevillageidiot,andanincompetentchiefofpolice.Whatfollowsisnotraditionalactionfilm,butathrillerwithsnatchesofcomedy,inwhichtheenemyisn’thiddenbehindmasks,butisinthemindsoftheliberators.Beforetheyact,theyhavetoovercometheirpersonaldemons.Comparisonstotheschoolhostage-takingsinBeslanandKazanareobvious,yetKaratas–themythicalvillagewheremuchofdirectorAdilkhanYerzhanov’sworkisset–couldbeanywhere.Itisuniversallyacknowledgedthatcrisesbringoutpeople'struenatures.
