宋恭婷
回复 林淑娟 :校园突击MaskedfigureswithmachinegunsmarchintothesecondaryschoolinKaratas,takethepupilshostage,andexecuteoneofthem.Theymakenodemands.Silentterroristheirmodusoperandi.Seeingasthearmywilltaketwodaystoarriveduetoasnowstorm,mathsteacherTazshidecidestoassemblehisownassaultteam:hisex-wife,thegymteacher,thecowardlyschoolprincipal,analcoholicnightwatchman,thevillageidiot,andanincompetentchiefofpolice.Whatfollowsisnotraditionalactionfilm,butathrillerwithsnatchesofcomedy,inwhichtheenemyisn’thiddenbehindmasks,butisinthemindsoftheliberators.Beforetheyact,theyhavetoovercometheirpersonaldemons.Comparisonstotheschoolhostage-takingsinBeslanandKazanareobvious,yetKaratas–themythicalvillagewheremuchofdirectorAdilkhanYerzhanov’sworkisset–couldbeanywhere.Itisuniversallyacknowledgedthatcrisesbringoutpeople'struenatures.
黄文彬
回复 钱希康 :金手指王鍾初次執導《金手指》，叫人刮目相看。繼承了張徹陽剛勇猛的電影風格，將男性情誼發揮成新一代警隊精神。「金手指」意指向警方告密的線人。販毒集團殺害線人啞巴。警方找到啞巴的好友李修賢作臥底，修為友報仇，甘冒險挺身與警方合作，提供線索，追查真兇，最後找出集團主腦，卻是另有其人。八十年代，市民做證人的題材，非常大膽，《金手指》開創寫實警匪片的電影主流，直接影響李修賢後來執導的《公僕》和《皇家飯》。王鍾處理飛車鎗戰場面，火爆刺激，故事峰迴路轉，節奏明快。
